Skip to main content

La Bête Humaine

Director: Jean Renoir
Year: 1938
Run-time: 1 hr 40 min

- This isn't an easy film to love in 2020, since its protagonist murders women uncontrollably yet is meant to elicit a strange kind of sympathy, and the female lead is pegged as manipulative, coercing her lovers to murder.  Critics of the time period agreed that there is something deeply disturbing about this film based on an Emile Zola film.  Nevertheless, the performance of Jean Gabin and Simone Simon are fascinating to watch, and if the film took greater liberties with its source material, it might have been one of Renoir's finest.  As it is, it is a forerunner to some of the worst trends of film noir, as well as some of the best, and I wouldn't recommend it for everyone.

- This is Jean Gabin's fourth film on the list in two years, a feat I'm not sure will be repeated. I might call Gabin the best actor of the 1930's.  It's fascinating to compare him to a male lead like Cary Grant.  Whereas Grant always seems desperate to control any scene he's in, Gabin was always content to let the actors around him shine just as brightly. He wanted to play lost and troubled leads, and even though his character in this film was not the most well-conceived, he still turns in an excellent performance.


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Big Sleep

Director: Howard Hawks Year: 1946 While  The Maltese Falcon cares deeply about its plot, which ends up pretty simple if very well-paced, The Big Sleep  revels in its complexity, is extremely difficult to follow, even if it ultimately cares much more about its characters than most "puzzle films". This film clearly had a big influence on  Inherent Vice. I'm not sure I love it - my wife got so confused she couldn't keep watching - but I think there's certainly a lot more to it than most of the noirs we've seen so far. Bacall is excellent, and Bogart is just perfect. I would certainly watch it again to see how it holds up now that I have a better idea of what's going on.
Post a Comment
Read more

The Docks of New York

Director: Josef von Sternberg Year: 1928 Run-time: 1 hr 16 min Source: Youtube Silent films were certainly on their way out in 1928, at least if you were an American studio director who's not Chaplin or Keaton, and this was one of those little gems that went largely unseen due to that transition.  It feels a bit like both a proto-noir and a proto-gangster film, but neither of those labels quite fit.  It's actually an effective, unconventional romance film, something that starts out cynical but ends up very sweet. I enjoyed the film more than I thought I would, but with this entry in the list, I can't help but notice the big American studio system of the mid-century is falling into place, with Keaton now making films like The Cameraman  for MGM (a studio which would ultimately ruin his career), and this film released by the newly renamed Paramount Pictures.  Along with it, the rough edges are getting smoothed down a little bit.  Certainly, the standards in...
Post a Comment
Read more

Le Quai des brumes (Port Of Shadows)

Director: Marcel Carné Year: 1938 Run-time: 1 hr 31 min - This is the first of two Carné films on the list from 1938.  We haven't talked much about French poetic realism, the style pioneered by Pepe le Moko  (also starring Jean Gabin), but this is where that style heavily overlaps with what would become film noir (Wikipedia claims this was one of the first films to be called as such).  The tropes of noir are so heavily associated with post-war depression and malaise that it's pretty shocking to see these same tropes show up before the war - the French government agreed, and even banned this film for a time as not representative of the French spirit.  It's an excellent film, though. From my perspective, both of these early Carné works show clear ties to the Marseilles trilogy - this one, because of the persistent theme of the sea as a place for escape and loss of identity. - I am much more in love with the French acting style of the 30's than I am...
Post a Comment
Read more