Skip to main content

Человек с кино-аппаратом (Man With A Movie Camera)

Director: Dziga Vertov
Year: 1929
Runtime: 1 hr 7 min
Source: Amazon Video

Wikipedia

Kyle Kallgren's Video Analysis

Notable for: Being one of the most critically acclaimed silent films (although not at the time of release).  It was voted the 8th best film of all time by Sight and Sound in 2012, and the best documentary of all time a few years later.

Critics respond to many things about the film, including but not limited to:
  • Putting the act of film-making front and center, including the editing process (here undertaken by Vertov's wife).  Previously the task of editing was considered secondary to artistic vision.
  • The invention or innovation (there is some debate here) of many editing techniques, including split screen, stop or slow motion, and double exposure. Vertov wanted his audience to know that this was not magic but a mechanical science.
  • Vertov's radical belief in the power of cinema to create a communal, universal perspective on the world, independent of any authoritarian (read: directorial) vision.  His faith in technology to guide us to the betterment of our species is the very definition of modernism, and that makes Vertov's film the culmination of the "city symphony" movement (films like Manhatta and Nothing But Time).
Verdict: Devoid of historical context, MWAMC still makes for a fun watch, since its fast pacing dispels most of the boredom that usually attaches to such experimental works.  It's a much more joyous work than I was expecting, especially after the industrial nightmare that is The Eleventh Year.  There are still moments that revel in the joining of man and machine, but that impulse is just one of many competing ideas.  There's a lot of humor, and even eroticism, in this film.

For me, the most interesting aspect of Vertov's philosophy is how it compares to modern technological utopianism, currently shattered in the ruins of our realization that social media is a prison.  Vertov's vision came true in many ways, the least of which being that everyone is a man with a movie camera.

Best paired with:  Knausgaard's anti-fiction fiction provides an interesting humanist counterpoint to Vertov's.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Bringing Up Baby

Director: Howard Hawks Year: 1938 Run-time: 1 hr 42 min - Bringing Up Baby  is in my mind the epitome of the screwball comedy, and probably its finest example.  Hepburn and Grant are just so perfect in their roles, and the level of constant absurdity gets to the point where it overrides any cultural datedness and just becomes fun.  (The main exception is the Irish stereotype, but given that he is justified in how he behaves, it's excusable.)  I was a bit shocked to discover that this was not a commercial success, and indeed almost ruined Hepburn's career (she had the most to lose, given how novel her quirky performance is). - Looking back at the three screwballs so far on this list, it never occurred to me before how the genre seems to rely on a rich and "privileged" female lead to be the one to challenge and emasculate the male lead.  Perhaps that was the acceptable way to present it to a depression-era audience?
Post a Comment
Read more

Partie de campagne (A Day In the Country)

Director: Jean Renoir Year: 1936 Run-time: 40 min - You can tell that French film is thriving in 1936 by the fact that a film by Renoir is the worst of the last three on the list.  (Renoir has two 1936 films on the list - and other classics from this year that didn't make the cut.)  That's only really due to its brevity, and the fact that it wasn't properly finished due to extenuating circumstances.  What exists is still pretty excellent - putting the elegant but slight story aside, it's Renoir's ode to the natural world, which never quite came through before due to the bluntness of 1930's cinematography.  In fact, it's the only Renoir film I've seen in which he channels something of his father's eye for natural beauty (a fact he alludes to himself in a later commentary he gave on the film).
Post a Comment
Read more

The Cat Concerto

Directors: William Hanna and Joseph Barbera Year: 1947 I'm sure it's no coincidence that music plays such a strong role in many of the animated films featured on the list. By this point, there's nothing especially novel about this Tom and Jerry  short by another great animation studio led by Hanna and Barbera, except that the execution is so spot-on. This is eight minutes of pure delight. 
Post a Comment
Read more