Skip to main content

Menschen am Sonntag (People on Sunday)

Director: Robert Siodmak and Edgar G. Ulmer
Year: 1930
Run-time: 1 hr 13 min
Source: Criterion Channel

Wikipedia

Notable for: Having all the hallmarks of a modern independent movie, including non-actors playing versions of themselves, and largely improvised scenes.   The film brought together five filmmakers at the beginning of their careers - most of them would later emigrate to America and pioneer the film noir genre.

The film is also the perfect snapshot of Weimar Germany at its peak, showing five aimless young people with no idea of the tragedy that their country would endure before too long.  The film's naturalistic style would become hugely influential in America, and is another instance of the free exchange of ideas between America and Germany at the time.  Along with Pandora's Box and its epitome of the American "flapper", this film would embody American glorification of the working class.  (In many ways it parallels Mother Krause's Journey to Happiness, without that film's proletarian message.

Verdict:  The performances are outstanding - I blithely assumed that the intertitles proclaiming the stars as non-actors were exaggerations.  In what is a very simple film, there are so many wonderful details to unpack, like the male characters' grandstanding or the females' rivalry.  There's nothing here that wouldn't be done in a more sophisticated way later on, but as a piece of cultural history it's fascinating.  This is one that I wished I owned in some fashion.

Perfect Pairing:  It would make a good prologue to the Joe Swanberg series Easy.  I'm not the first to suggest People on Sunday as the first "mumblecore" feature, but in its dealing with simple and even mundane romantic themes, it has even more in common than basic style.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Bringing Up Baby

Director: Howard Hawks Year: 1938 Run-time: 1 hr 42 min - Bringing Up Baby  is in my mind the epitome of the screwball comedy, and probably its finest example.  Hepburn and Grant are just so perfect in their roles, and the level of constant absurdity gets to the point where it overrides any cultural datedness and just becomes fun.  (The main exception is the Irish stereotype, but given that he is justified in how he behaves, it's excusable.)  I was a bit shocked to discover that this was not a commercial success, and indeed almost ruined Hepburn's career (she had the most to lose, given how novel her quirky performance is). - Looking back at the three screwballs so far on this list, it never occurred to me before how the genre seems to rely on a rich and "privileged" female lead to be the one to challenge and emasculate the male lead.  Perhaps that was the acceptable way to present it to a depression-era audience?

The Cat Concerto

Directors: William Hanna and Joseph Barbera Year: 1947 I'm sure it's no coincidence that music plays such a strong role in many of the animated films featured on the list. By this point, there's nothing especially novel about this Tom and Jerry  short by another great animation studio led by Hanna and Barbera, except that the execution is so spot-on. This is eight minutes of pure delight. 

The Land Beyond The Sunset

Director: Harold M. Shaw Year: 1912 Runtime: 0:14 Source: Youtube This is a great short film to watch if you're spending a hot summer in the city.  It was made by a little-known director as something of a PSA about the Fresh Air Fund, a non-profit which let inner-city children vacation in the countryside. (It's still going strong today!) A poor young newsie with an endearingly tattered cap gets to take a break from child labor and parental abuse, and join a group of kids for one day in the great outdoors. In many ways this would be the prototype of the heartwarming Pixar short, if the ending wasn't so poignant and bittersweet.  It's such a simple little film, but one that's absolutely worth 14 minutes of your life.