Skip to main content

Man's Castle

Director: Frank Borzage
Year: 1933
Run-time: 1 hr 6 min
Source: Youtube

- This is, I think, the last Borzage film on the list.  It sticks with the general theme of a romance under assault from the world.  However, the Spencer Tracy character breaks the general archetype, straining the limits of the audience's sympathy with the way he treats his doting lover in a way that a modern audience would find uncomfortable, but he does mostly redeem himself in the end.  In a way, the tension between the Borzage melodramatic style and Tracy's wit and shenanigans make this film more "accessible" than Borzage's earlier work.

- However, audiences didn't seem to think so.  This wasn't Tracy's breakout role, although he had been slowly gaining traction for a few years.  Loretta Young is in my opinion the real star here.  The way that she devotes herself to the hardened Spencer Tracy could come off as weak in a lesser actress, but I think Young pulls it off in a way that makes it clear she's trying to better her own life in the only way she knows how.

- The way that Young controls her expressions reminded me perversely of Tim Curry in Rocky Horror Picture Show.  I would love to see an interview about the old actresses that inspired Curry's performance, as anyone watching him sing "Whatever happened...to Fay Wray?" knows how indebted the whole production is to the golden age of movies.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Cat Concerto

Directors: William Hanna and Joseph Barbera Year: 1947 I'm sure it's no coincidence that music plays such a strong role in many of the animated films featured on the list. By this point, there's nothing especially novel about this Tom and Jerry  short by another great animation studio led by Hanna and Barbera, except that the execution is so spot-on. This is eight minutes of pure delight. 

The Land Beyond The Sunset

Director: Harold M. Shaw Year: 1912 Runtime: 0:14 Source: Youtube This is a great short film to watch if you're spending a hot summer in the city.  It was made by a little-known director as something of a PSA about the Fresh Air Fund, a non-profit which let inner-city children vacation in the countryside. (It's still going strong today!) A poor young newsie with an endearingly tattered cap gets to take a break from child labor and parental abuse, and join a group of kids for one day in the great outdoors. In many ways this would be the prototype of the heartwarming Pixar short, if the ending wasn't so poignant and bittersweet.  It's such a simple little film, but one that's absolutely worth 14 minutes of your life.

I Walked With A Zombie

Director: Jacques Torneur Year: 1943 Run-time: 1 hr 9 min - If I were a snarky Youtube reviewer, I would subtitle this movie " Jane Eyre , with added sexism and racism". And there is some truth to that - the "wife in the attic" becomes the titular zombie, but her fate is largely due to her own desires to run away. Also, although Torneur takes a more honest look at the effects of colonialism and slavery than any contemporary film, the needs of the schlock-horror setup means that, yes, the powers of voodoo are actually real. Ultimately, this was a fascinating film, but a deeply flawed one. Torneur has a wide oeuvre, though, so I have rising hopes for the others of his films on the list.